Exploring the Phonak Roger: Simon Haggis’ Experience
Written by Simon Haggis
Freelance Sound Recordist and Music Playback Operator, Simon Haggis, discusses his experiences with Phonak in-ear solutions in the challenging world of music video production.
Alongside the usual gamut of location recording jobs, I’m often asked to playback music on different kinds of shoots. Initially, this was primarily for TV commercials, which are the bulk of my sound recording work. Typically, these setups involve playing music through loudspeakers for a group of dancers, with a main talent miming along and happily selling home insurance. If the shoot occurs outside of a studio, the talent would need an in ear receiver in order to hear the track’s lyrics more clearly.
As time progresses, I began working on more music videos, particularly ones where pop artists and their label management specify that it must be ‘silent on set’, which means the unreleased track cannot be played out loud at any time during the shoot. This is because they don’t want to risk paparazzi or members of crew or public recording the new track and leaking it ahead of release.

In these situations, a wireless in-ear system becomes essential as costumes often don’t allow a radio pack and wires to be hidden. It’s also a safety issue if the talent is throwing themselves around performing; we want to avoid any risk of injury from a pack digging in if there’s a fall.
The Twofold Challenge: Audio Quality and Range
When it comes to wireless in-ear systems, the challenges are twofold: achieving excellent audio quality and maintaining reliable range in a tiny device that fits comfortably in the artist’s ear.
Audio quality – The artist firstly needs to hear the track playing in their ears clearly and with enough volume and clarity so it can be heard above any surrounding external noise, allowing them to focus on delivering their best performance for their video. Supporting artists or dancers also need to hear the track clearly and loudly enough to be able to properly engage with the music they’re hearing and perform their dance routines. Tinny sound just doesn’t deliver the impact needed.
Range – This is perhaps the most significant challenge. Range dropouts break everyone’s creative flow and are unacceptable when artists, dancers, and film crews are ready and waiting to go on set.
All the available wireless in-ear devices are intended to be used as hearing aids for speech or prompts for TV presenters in quieter studios or meeting rooms. These systems are designed to be sufficient to cover a few metres from a transmitter, optimally positioned close to the wearer.
If an actor on a drama set needs direction or lines feeding to their ear piece, then that doesn’t really present any audio quality or range problems. A transmitter can simply be hidden on set and it’s a nice quiet and controlled environment.
The requirements can often be more challenging on music videos where the talent is moving over a much wider area in an uncontrolled public space. For example, they might walk off down a windy beach, or they’re singing in a bed being driven hundreds of metres down Pall Mall on the back of a lorry (because music videos).
Transitioning from Analog to Digital
For years, I relied on the older analog Phonak Invisity system. It offered a good, reliable range with a decent antenna set up on VHF but often fell short in audio quality, producing a hissy, noisy output that wasn’t ideal for music. It was just about good enough but I did want something better signal quality wise.
When the Invisity system was discontinued in 2020, I decided to hire the newer digital Phonak Roger system that ran on 2.4GHz Wi-Fi, with a view to seeing how it fared before potentially investing in it.
On its first run out on a music video, the Phonak Roger system impressed me with its noticeably cleaner signal and increased volume – a definite win on the audio quality front. However, I wasn’t quite prepared for just how limited the range was.
Total drop outs (it’s all or nothing with digital signals) would happen with head turns less than 5 metres away – and that was inside a studio where its Wi-Fi signal could bounce off the walls. I resorted to the usual tricks of positioning the transmitter high on an antenna mast to keep line of sight and moving my playback cart up to the edge of the frame. But in the afternoon I was back using the Invisity system again to ensure the signal remained consistent and my heart rate stayed lower!
Despite these challenges, the superior audio quality of the Phonak Roger system motivated me to persist. A bit of research and a few calls later to Andy at Raycom, one of the Phonak distributors, convinced me it was possible to achieve better range with a few tweaks. So I bought a Roger BaseStation and a couple of in-ear receivers to get started.

Despite these challenges, the superior audio quality of the Phonak Roger system motivated me to persist. A bit of research and a few calls later to Andy at Raycom, one of the Phonak distributors, convinced me it was possible to achieve better range with a few tweaks. So I bought a Roger BaseStation and a couple of in-ear receivers to get started.
Enhancing the Phonak Roger System’s Range
The first thing to do was to get hold of a Wi-Fi signal booster which screws directly onto the front of the Phonak Roger BaseStation, providing a decent antenna in comparison to the standard stubby aerial. There’s some signal loss on 2.4GHz if you use even the shortest cable to connect this booster, so it has to be directly attached to the BaseStation. It needs to be carefully supported so it keeps a good connection and doesn’t snap off. With this setup, I achieved a range of about 30-40 metres before head turns would cause drop outs, so that was good enough for most shoots in a studio space.
Without the addition of a signal booster, the Phonak Roger system wasn’t fit for my intended purpose. I know a few people that have got themselves into trouble thinking this would work straight out of the box when they hired them – be warned!

For location shoots outside, I also picked up a couple of the Phonak Roger Repeaters, on the recommendation from Raycom. These enabled the BaseStation’s signal to leapfrog along to extend its range. Strategic placement of two of these Repeaters hidden around a location gave a pretty wide triangular zone of good reception. I once had a shoot with an artist running round a circus and then riding off on a horse, and the Repeaters handled it pretty well.
It was a step forward but I still wanted to find a way of guaranteeing coverage over a larger space. The hallelujah moment came when I called up Andy again and said, “I’d almost like a series of transmitters that the earpieces switch between as the talent moves around”. His very welcome suggestion was to use the cloning function in the Phonak Roger software. This is a feature designed to achieve exactly what I was after by using additional BaseStation transmitters that have been ‘cloned’, so they both transmit on the same frequency and can operate to cover different zones.
Achieving Rock-Solid Range with Cloning
I now normally run two Phonak Roger BaseStations working in tandem to cover most situations. I position a BaseStation transmitter at either extreme of where a talent will move during a shot i.e. their start and end points. As the talent moves away from one BaseStation they move into the transmission zone of the next BaseStation, and the signal seamlessly flicks over. It’s this cloning function that has achieved rock solid reliable range for me – more expense with the additional transmitters but well worth it for peace of mind. Plus of course, redundancy with spare kit is always good.

Fast forward a few years, and after gradually refining my setup, I’m now really happy I have a flexible, location friendly set up that is easy to use and rock solid. The accompanying pictures hopefully explain the set up I’ve settled on.
Setting Up for Success
The BaseStation transmitters are housed in Nanuk cases that mount on top of a C-Stand to get them nice and high above talent to give the best transmission coverage. The cases are as slimline as I could get away with so that they don’t get blown over outdoors in windy conditions. It’s important to have a robust set up as music videos throw up all sorts of challenging locations; I spent a couple of days on the end of a pier extending out over the North Sea in December being lashed by the wind and rain.

Each case contains the transmitter, a Wi-Fi signal booster, a G4 receiver (that picks up the music track transmitted from my cart) and an NP1 battery to power everything. When a shot moves we just pick up the C-Stands and reposition them closer to the new position. No cables or wires in shot means it’s quick and easy to hide to ensure good reception once more.
I position my playback cart between the two C-Stands to have line of sight to both, and then I can rely on the analog Sennheiser G4’s to do the heavy lifting longer range radio transmission. The C-Stands placed as close as possible to the artist give the 2.4GHz Wi-Fi signal an easier shorter range task. If I’m not able to achieve line of sight to where the C-Stands are positioned, then I can fall back on hardwiring round corners with XLR cables into the Roger Basestation transmitter
For belt and braces coverage, I also sometimes give the talent a Phonak Roger Repeater to put in their pocket (if they have one) on the opposite side of the body to their in-ear receiver.
Maximising Performance
Several key points are worth mentioning:
- V2 Earpieces: These help achieve better range compared to the original versions.
- 3.5mm Jack Input: I’ve found that using this input on the BaseStation achieves a slightly hotter signal than the XLR input.
- Factory Volume Settings: By default, the in-ear receivers aren’t set to maximum volume. You can adjust this using the Phonak Roger Touch Screen device or you can go into the Raycom office and have Andy at Raycom set them to maximum, as I did.
To ensure I feed the Phonak Roger system with the best signal I can, my playback cart has a Macbook running ProTools which feeds an SSL Big Six mixer acting as my audio interface.

It’s not essential to have a mixing board like this but I like having fast hands on control rather than fiddling around with a mouse and computer.
On some shoots, such is the level of secrecy around an unreleased track, the dancers might be fed an instrumental only version of the track to their in ears, or a click track, while the main talent receives the full vocal version. The SSL mixer makes this easy to set up, feeding another BaseStation transmitter.
Being a hybrid analog/digital console with Aux Sends, means I can also feed talent the signal from handheld mics from a Director and another from a 1st AD. This allows direct communication to the talent’s earpiece for cues or when they might be out of normal 1st AD shouting range, and helps a day to run smoothly.
The SSL desk sends the audio out to a Sennheiser G3 transmitter, which has an omni paddle antenna mounted up high on a mast on the cart. This sends audio out to the Sennheiser G3 receivers on the BaseStations on the C-Stands, and also handles transmitting timecode out to a digislate. On some shoots with American artists, there is sometimes a requirement that any radio transmission of an unreleased track has to be digitally encrypted. To achieve this I swap out the analog Sennheiser’s for a Zaxcom digitally encrypted system.
Conclusion
My rig is designed to try and achieve the best-sounding, and most reliable wireless in-ear system to cope with the unfailingly bonkers demands of working on music videos.
It’s been used on beaches, in a zoo, football pitches, busy high streets, open countryside, and with talent riding a horse, in a car or up in the air on a trapeze. The only thing it can’t cope with is talent going underwater…


On that note I’m very grateful to be able to rely on Raycom’s level of support. On an Ed Sheeran shoot I was informed the day before he’d be singing whilst in the sea and would very likely be going under the waves – did I have a waterproof in ear system? No, but Jilly at Raycom got me some spare stock of in-ear receivers delivered to location for the next morning. I think we got through five in ears after they took a thorough soaking in salt water. God bless music videos.
In my experience good location sound, whether recordings or playback, is rarely commented on but is essential in supporting the creative process on set. I was lucky enough to work on a Taylor Swift video for a week and the only feedback I got was a smile and a thank you when the in-ear was handed back each day. That for me was a great stamp of approval in the set up and the best result possible; everything just worked without fuss to support the shoot.

Andy at Raycom has been instrumental in helping me make gradual improvements to the set up over time so many thanks to him and to everyone at Raycom for keeping things running smoothly.
For more insights into my work, visit my website: www.simonhaggis.com.